Hiring a Geriatric Care Manager in Central Ohio: What an Aging Life Care Professional Does and When One Is Worth It

When a parent needs more coordination than any one family member can give, a professional care manager can be the person who holds the whole picture. Here is what they do, what they do not, and how to choose one.

By Ray Kessler, Certified Senior Advisor · Published October 5, 2026

The Problem a Care Manager Solves

Picture a daughter in Denver whose mother lives in Westerville. In the span of one month her mother has a fall, a hospital stay, a short rehab stint, and a new prescription list from three different doctors. The daughter has a spreadsheet, a stack of discharge papers, and a growing sense that nobody is looking at the whole picture. Each professional she talks to sees one slice. The hospital sees the admission, the rehab sees the therapy goals, the pharmacy sees the refill, and the family sees all of it at once, usually from a distance and usually at night.

A geriatric care manager exists for exactly that gap. The role goes by several names, including care manager, care coordinator, and Aging Life Care Professional, which is the term used by the Aging Life Care Association, the national professional group for the field. The job is to assess an older adult's situation, build a plan, line up the people and services that carry it out, and keep checking that the plan still fits. Think of a general contractor for a parent's care: the contractor does not lay every brick, but someone has to know what is happening on the whole site.

This guide is for central Ohio families weighing whether to hire one. It is deliberately about the decision rather than a sales pitch. For many families a care manager is unnecessary, and for some they are the single most useful hire they will make.

What a Care Manager Actually Does

The work usually starts with an assessment, often in the home. A care manager looks at health and medications, mobility and fall risk, memory and judgment, nutrition, finances at a high level, the safety of the house, and the family's own dynamics. The output is a written care plan that says what is needed, who will provide it, and what to watch for next.

From there the day-to-day tasks tend to fall into a few groups. Coordination means keeping doctors, therapists, home care agencies and family on the same page, and sometimes attending appointments so that someone takes notes and asks the questions the family would have asked. Problem solving means handling the unplanned: a caregiver who quits, a medication change, an insurance denial, a parent who refuses help. Advocacy means speaking up with hospitals and facilities on the older adult's behalf. Transition support means helping with a move, whether that is from home to assisted living or from a hospital to rehab and back home. Some care managers also provide ongoing monitoring, visiting on a regular schedule so that small changes get noticed before they become emergencies.

What a care manager generally does not do is deliver hands-on personal care, practice medicine, give legal advice, or manage investments. They refer to those professionals. A good one will tell you plainly where their role stops, and will have a short list of elder law attorneys, home care agencies, and financial professionals they trust. If you are interested in the home care side, our guide to hiring an in-home caregiver through an agency versus privately covers that separate decision.

Situations Where One Is Worth Considering

The clearest case is the long-distance family. Our guide for out-of-state siblings evaluating assisted living describes how hard it is to judge care from a distance, and a local professional who can lay eyes on a parent every few weeks closes much of that gap. The same applies to families who live in Columbus but work long hours, or who have young children and a parent in Pickerington or Delaware who needs more attention than a weekend visit provides.

A second case is the crisis with too many moving parts. After a hospital stay, families are often asked to choose a rehab or home plan within a day or two. Our explanation of how hospital discharge planning works in Columbus shows what the hospital's own staff will and will not do. A hospital discharge planner works for the hospital and is focused on a safe discharge, while a private care manager works for you and stays involved after the discharge paperwork is done.

A third case is the family that disagrees. When siblings hold different views about how much help a parent needs, a neutral professional assessment can lower the temperature. It is easier to argue with a brother than with a written evaluation from someone who visited the house. If that sounds familiar, see our piece on what to do when siblings disagree about a parent's care.

A fourth case is dementia or a complicated medical picture, where the right level of care is changing every few months and the family needs an expert eye on the timing of each step. If memory care is on the horizon, our Franklin County memory care decision guide pairs well with a care manager's assessment.

When is it probably not needed? If a parent is mostly independent, a family member lives nearby and has the time, and the needs are straightforward, a care manager may be more structure than the situation calls for. In that case a call to the local Area Agency on Aging, described in our guide to what the central Ohio Area Agency on Aging does, may be enough to connect you to free services and a free assessment for programs you might qualify for.

Private Care Managers Versus the Free and Public Options

Families sometimes confuse several roles that sound alike. A private care manager is hired and paid by the family, works for the family, and can take on as much or as little as the contract says. A hospital or rehab discharge planner is employed by the facility and works within the length of a stay. A case manager through a Medicaid waiver program is assigned by the program, follows that program's rules, and coordinates only the services the program covers. A social worker at a doctor's office or health system may help with a specific referral. Each is useful, and none of them is the same as someone whose only client is your parent.

This matters because the public roles are free to the family while private care management is not, and the right choice depends on what your parent needs. A parent who qualifies for a waiver program already has a case manager, and a private care manager would work alongside that person rather than replacing them. A parent who does not qualify, or who needs more attention than a program provides, is where private help tends to make sense.

How Fees Work and What to Ask Up Front

Care management is typically billed by the hour, sometimes with an initial assessment fee and sometimes with a monthly arrangement for ongoing monitoring. Rates vary by professional, by the complexity of the case, and by how much travel is involved. We do not publish a price for central Ohio because we have not found a reliable, published source for one, and an invented number would only mislead you. Ask for a written fee schedule before you agree to anything, and ask what is billed separately, such as mileage, phone time, and time spent attending appointments.

Medicare generally does not pay for private care management, and long-term care insurance policies differ on whether they cover it, so check the policy language or ask the insurer. For the broader picture of what care costs in Ohio, our cost of care page lays out the state-level figures and explains why we do not offer a Columbus-specific number for services where none is published.

Because the meter is running, it helps to define the job narrowly at the start. A one-time assessment and plan is a very different commitment from open-ended monitoring. Many families begin with the assessment and decide afterward whether to continue, which keeps the cost proportionate to the need.

How to Vet a Care Manager Before You Sign

Care management is a field where credentials vary, and as far as we know, "care manager" is not a protected title in Ohio the way "registered nurse" or "licensed social worker" is. That means the title alone tells you very little, and the questions you ask matter. Start with the underlying background. Many care managers are nurses, social workers, or gerontologists, and you can ask for the specific license and then check it with the Ohio board that issues it. Ask whether they belong to the Aging Life Care Association and whether they hold a recognized certification, then confirm both directly with the organization rather than relying on a website badge.

Next, ask about experience in your parent's situation. Someone who spends most of their time on dementia cases will bring different skills than someone who mostly handles post-surgical recovery. Ask how long they have worked in the Columbus area and which hospitals, rehab communities, and home care agencies they work with regularly, because local relationships are a large part of what you are paying for.

Then ask about the mechanics. Who is the client, your parent or the family member who is hiring? How often will they visit, and who covers when they are away? How do they communicate with out-of-town relatives, and how fast do they return calls in an emergency? Request a sample care plan with names removed, a written service agreement, and two references from families, not just professional contacts.

Finally, ask about conflicts of interest. A care manager who receives referral fees from a facility or agency has a reason to steer you toward it. Some operate under a model that disclaims referral fees entirely, and you are entitled to ask directly. We apply the same standard to ourselves, and explain how we work on our editorial standards page.

Where a Care Manager Fits in a Larger Plan

A care manager is most effective when the legal and financial groundwork is already in place. If a parent has not signed a durable power of attorney and a health care power of attorney, the care manager can recommend an elder law attorney, but they cannot sign for your parent or make decisions that belong to the person who holds that authority. Our guide to the legal paperwork to complete before a care crisis explains what to have ready, and our overview of guardianship in Franklin County covers what happens when it has not been done and a parent can no longer sign.

It also helps to be clear about the care manager's role in relation to a facility. If your parent moves to assisted living, a care manager can attend the move-in, coordinate with the community's staff, and visit regularly in the early weeks, when the adjustment is hardest. Our guide to the first 30 days after an assisted living move shows what those weeks look like. If something goes wrong, the care manager is a useful ally, but the formal channels for complaints remain the long-term care ombudsman and Adult Protective Services.

A Short Plan for the Next Two Weeks

If you are weighing this decision now, resist the urge to hire the first name you find. In the first few days, write down the specific problems you want solved, such as no one is tracking medications, we cannot agree, or I live four hours away and cannot judge what is happening. A care manager hired against a defined list of problems is easier to evaluate than one hired for a general sense of worry.

In the second week, speak with two or three candidates using the questions above, compare the written fee schedules, and ask each one how they would approach the first thirty days. Consider starting with a single assessment, and bring your siblings into the conversation so that the hire is a family decision rather than one person's burden. Keep your parent at the center of it, since the best care plan is one your parent has helped shape.

Finally, remember that a care manager supplements the family rather than replaces it. The most successful arrangements are ones in which relatives remain involved, visit when they can, and treat the professional as a partner who sees what they cannot. If you would like help sorting out whether a care manager, an Area Agency on Aging referral, or a direct tour of a community is the right first step, that is what Darlene is here for, and it costs your family nothing.

Frequently Asked Questions